50+ Non-Candy Easter Egg Ideas Kids Will Love

This post probably contains affiliate links. As an Amazon associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means I may be rewarded monetarily or otherwise upon purchase through these links, at no additional cost to you. If you want to read the boring legal stuff, you can find my full disclosure here.

Find non-candy easter egg ideas for every age group! The perfect ideas for babies, toddlers, preschoolers, and school aged kids that they will love!

With every holiday that rolls around, it seems like candy and food coloring are lurking around every corner.

I love it when Easter comes around because it’s so easy to completely skip over the candy.

My favorite approach to Easter has to be celebrating the fact that it’s finally getting warmer outside. It’s time to prep for springtime, playing outside, and even summer vacation that will be here before we know it!

A fun tradition we can’t wait to start this year with our own kids is the famous annual Easter egg hunt. But we’re still being very careful about sugar intake (especially with the smallest guy who is likely to get sticky hands at every corner).

But sometimes it’s hard to figure out what exactly to put inside the plastic eggs since they’re so small and the PERFECT size for candy. So what do you do instead?

Thankfully there are lots of options.

It varies a little depending on the age of your kids, but you can have fun with this regardless. So if you’re looking for a list of non-candy easter egg fillers, I’ve got you covered for every age group.

No matter if you’ve got a fresh new baby, a wobbly toddler, a preschooler, or even a school-aged kiddo — you’re sure to find plenty of great ideas for little kids on this list.

Let’s get to it, shall we?

Why Choose Non-Candy Easter Egg Ideas?

Before we dive into the list, let’s talk about why non-candy easter egg filler ideas options can be a great choice for your kiddos.

  • They’re a much healthier approach to Easter as you’re significantly reducing sugar intake
  • Options like toys, puzzles, and art supplies can help spark creativity and provide options to engage in imaginative play.
  • While candy is consumed in what feels like a blink of an eye, non-candy options will allow kids to have fun for much, much longer!
  • It can encourage outdoor play with kiddos, which is perfect with the weather warming up!
  • Depending on the fillers you choose, it can also be educational in ways that kiddos won’t even notice.

Choosing the Right Easter Egg Fillers

Selecting the perfect Easter egg fillers requires a bit of thought, especially when you’re steering clear of sweet treats. You still want a good easter egg hunt but without the sugar.

You can also consider getting larger eggs when you’re selecting plastic easter eggs for everything to go inside.

Here are my best tips on how to choose the best options:

  • Make sure items are safe and suitable for your child’s age. The last thing we want is to present an accidental choking hazard!
  • Consider your child’s current interests and choose things that align. If they’re a budding artist, stickers and beads would be a great choice. If they love playing outside, you can get planting supplies to introduce them to gardening.
  • Choose items that encourage being active as the weather gets warmer. Jump ropes, chalk, and bubbles are some of our favorites for this!
  • Check the dollar store as they have so many great options for fun easter egg fillers! Just browsing the isles can help you spot some fun items.

Now that we’ve got that out of the way, let’s take a look at my list of ideas broken up by age!

Non-Candy Easter Egg Ideas for Babies

Babies might not have a single clue regarding what’s going on, but that doesn’t mean they can’t enjoy the fun too! Here’s a list of non-candy ideas that are perfect for our little drool boxes.

  • Small snacks such as puffs or freeze-dried fruit
  • Baby socks or booties
  • Teethers
  • Mini bath toys
  • Pacifier clip

And for those items that don’t fit into a typical-sized egg:

  • Stuffed animal
  • Board books
  • Sensory toys
  • Rattle
  • Teething necklace
  • Bibs
  • Blankets
  • Feeding utensils
  • Clothing
  • Bath crayons
  • Stacking toys

Non-Candy Easter Egg Ideas for Toddlers and Preschoolers

Toddlers and preschoolers are such a fun age group for Easter. They get to start doing Easter egg hunts and enjoy the Easter bunny.

But the tiniest amount of sugar and they’re bouncing off the walls. Thankfully, there are lots of good options that they will love. Here are some better ideas to fill eggs with!

  • Fruit snacks or dried fruit
  • Puzzle pieces
  • Bouncy balls
  • Small toys for the bath
  • Hot wheels
  • Finger puppets
  • Stickers
  • Playdough
  • Temporary tattoos
  • Small sidewalk chalk
  • Stamps
  • Slap bracelets
  • Themed band-aids
  • Hairbows
  • Bath bombs
  • Mini bubbles

And for those bigger items:

  • Books
  • Small craft supplies
  • Flashcards
  • Glow sticks
  • Silly straws
  • Beach toys
  • Swimsuits
  • Floaties

Non-Candy Easter Egg Ideas for School-Age Kids

By the time kids are school-age, an Easter hunt is all about competition. Their interests have sure changed, though. Exact choices will depend on the age of your child and what they like. Here’s a list of even more ideas most suitable for this age group!

  • Squishy fidget toys
  • Harmonicas
  • Keychains
  • Slime
  • Kinetic sand
  • Silly putty
  • Marbles
  • Glow in the dark stars
  • Pony beads and string
  • Balloons
  • Seeds for planting
  • Mini bookmarks
  • Lip gloss
  • Hair ties
  • Gift certificates

And for those looking for something outside the egg:

  • Jump rope
  • Water squirt toys
  • Bubble makers
  • Paddleball sets
  • Legos
  • Gardening supplies
  • Board/card games


Easter can be so much fun but there’s no reason to complicate things with sugar overload. Non-candy Easter egg stuffers help contain kids and keep them healthy.

There are plenty of non-candy easter egg fillers that will be a huge hit with kids of all ages! No matter if it’s baby snacks for the drooly ones, art supplies for the preschoolers, or even a novelty fidget for the older kids — there’s something for everyone!

It’s such a fun way to enjoy the annual Easter egg hunt.

I hope you found lots of fun ideas that your kids will love. By choosing non-candy fillers, we’re not only making a healthier choice for our kiddos, but we’re also shifting the focus to things that are creative, educational, and play-based.

I hope you have a fun Easter this year!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *